Best Eye Liners for Women Pencil Blue

Pencil 7 Dec 2022 10+ Comments Open

1. Rimmel Exaggerate Definer Waterproof Self Sharpening

Rimmel Exaggerate Definer Waterproof Self Sharpening

This eye defining pencil has a deep rich color. Fine tipped for precise application. No more searching for a sharpener with the easy twist up self sharpening. Get ready for sexy eyes. Rimmel has a waterproof eye Definer that will keep your eyes looking good. No matter what your eye look is, this eyeliner pencil will compliment it. The eye definer is available in four colors. Try with their full line of Rimmel products. More than a century of legacy, leadership and innovation in affordable makeup, beauty products, and tools can be traced back to the first non-toxic mascara. They don't want to define your look. They are innovative to take you there. Compare Rimmel quality beauty products with other brands.

Brand: Rimmel

👤There is no protective seal on the product line. The item was unwrapped. I'm not going to use a product that I know isn't supposed to work the way it did. It was just terrible.

👤I am a make up artist. This deserves a single star. The tip broke off. I probably only used it five times. This photo is a bit deceiving. You are only purchasing one pencil.

👤The application is easy to use. As the day goes on, it leaves a lot of black in my eyes. I have to wipe my eyes to get rid of the eyeliner. I only apply on the top lashes. I've had better luck with cheap eyeliners.

👤I've been wearing this eyeliner for over eight years. It is the only eyeliner combo that I have ever had that is waterproof. This is the only eyeliner that I have ever had that lasts all day, because my eye doesn't have a tear duct system, and it constantly waters.

👤It's cheaper than Sephora. The product is basically the same as the one from Sephora. It's not greasy even. I have hooded eyes and it doesn't transfer from my lid to my crease. It is now.

👤I've been using another brand for 2 years and it came up on my Amazon as a suggestion. I'll try after reading the comments. It is amazing! I wore it early in the morning, went to a wedding and reception, and checked it out throughout the day. Excellent product! And a great price. You will not be disappointed.

👤I like the color and how dark it is. I bought the black one and my husband loved it, but it doesn't last very long, and I tried to use it under my eyes, but I can't say I'm a fan of it. It does well on the top if you prime it, but make sure you don't sweat or touch your eyes because it won't be waterproof. If I'm outside for a long time, I may not be able to use it. I give this a 4 out of 5 because I love the color and I wish it lasted longer.

👤I like Rimmel eyeliners. I apply in the morning, put some shadow or powder on, and it's good all day long. When I put it on, I just loved it, even though it was darker than I'd been expecting. It's a dark grey and has small, eye flattering sparkles in it. The sparkles were a bonus.

👤If you want a soft easy to apply eye liner, then this is for you. I suffer from watery eyes and need waterproof eye make up. Within a couple of minutes it was gone. I had to take it away.

👤The brown eyeliner is very opaque. The formula glides easily over the eyes and on the waterline. It has a long wearing finish that is long wearing on the waterline. It will not smudge like my other liners after it is set. The color is rich and retractable. It's perfectly suited to wear during the daytime because it's not as harsh as a black liner. I've been wearing this for over a month. I'm hooked. Great purchase. Would recommend. If my review was helpful, please let me know by clicking on theHelpful button.

2. Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner Hypoallergenic Fragrance Free

Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner Hypoallergenic Fragrance Free

It is smudge-proof and waterproof. 24H+ hold is long-lasting. Can be used after application for smokey eye look.

Brand: Marcelle

👤This is the 3rd pencil I have used. I have been wearing eyeliner since I was 16 years old. This is the best eyeliner I have ever purchased. Why. It glides on and never dries out. 2. Stays on all day. 3. My allergy prone eyes have never been bothered by this product. It's a good recommendation! The negative reviews do not reflect the product or why they were entered. This is a pencil made of wood. You can use a pencil sharpener. One review called this brush an eyeliner brush. This is a pencil, not a brush. This product is a 5 star product.

👤The reviews complained that they couldn't push or twist the pencil up. This is a standard eyeliner pencil that gets sharpened by using a pencil sharpener. It comes out with a great point every time, goes on smoothly, and lasts me all day without racoon eyes.

👤Be careful, buyer! The eyeliner is great. It doesn't bother my eyes and goes on without a hitch. The eyeliner does not twist up to raise up more eyeliner. The customer service repr. is not from Marcelle. I was told that I should use a makeup sharpener to make the top tip of the wand sharper. She said that I could buy the makeup sharpener from their sister company. Only Canada is where Annabelle ships in the USA. The top tip of the eyeliner crayon is plastic, not wood, and does not "sharpen" to allow more eyeliner crayon to be available for use. The eyeliner crayon is not accessible, so I can't use it.

👤I thought that wearing eyeliner on my waterline and not having major issues with my contact lens wouldn't happen. The problems I had been having with Urban Decay had gotten worse. The eyeliner made it's way down my face, it got in my eyes and my contacts, and my eyes became so irritated that I wouldn't wear my glasses for 2 hours. I thought maybe contacts and waterline eyeliner just don't work because I'd never wore makeup before. I don't know how I stumbled across this. I've been using it for about 2 months and it's been great. I have not had any of the problems I'd been having. I don't have to wipe my eyes dry before applying it. I do both eyes top and bottom, and one more quick touch over each one, and that's it. It works well with my contacts. It doesn't cause any of the issues I'd come to think I couldn't avoid. Total game change for me.

👤It stays on great, but there is no way to advance it in tube. It is not assessment at all for about 4 applications. Bad design.

👤I bought 3 different types of eyeliner and found this one to be the best - easy to use, precise lining, no smudge, stays on for hours, comes off with appropriate waterproof removal oil, I prefer this to the felt liner type tip. I've become allergic to some make-up products as I've gotten older, and I love that it's not a problem. I would like it to come in more colors.

3. Cosmetic Waterproof Highlighter Eyeshadow Professional

Cosmetic Waterproof Highlighter Eyeshadow Professional

6 colors makeup eyeliner pencils set, 6 different colors eyeshadow pens help you to design your own charm. It is easy to carry and use. It's ideal for every occasion. Good quality ingredients will last all day. It's suitable for salon, party, wedding or home. The eyeline pens can make a nice eye shadow. It is waterproof and sweat resistant, so you won't have to worry about makeup smudge or bloom. A makeup pen. The retractable pens can also be used as eyeliner pens. Also is a highlight pen. There is a sponge stick on the other side of the eyeliner pen. It's perfect for a smoky effect and dramatic look. It allows you to make your eyes look bigger.

Brand: Superthinker

👤I like eyeliners. They are creamy but not heavy. The product is encased in hard plastic and does not advance, even if you use a brisk stroke to put them across your eyelid. The tip is all you get. The eyeliner stick has no "smudger stick" on it. The colors are bright and brilliant. The lighter colors have to be applied with a lot of strokes so they won't last long, but the darker colors glide on brilliantly.

👤I wasn't expecting much for the price but it had a couple in the color range I needed and I figured it would make sense to try them, I really didn't expect them to be usable. If I put the liner on it, it would come off quickly, or it was not the shade I thought it was. I was wrong. I haven't tried the brown, but the rest work just as well as higher brand liners. It's great for the price. They're not going to compare brands that are so far out of my price range. They're a decent option if you need some color.

👤I love the easy glide on most of these pens, a few were hard to glide, but most are great and I live in a humid area. I have to use the lighter on some of them. Would buy it again. Solid 8n color applied.

👤I've had issues applying my eyeliner before. Friends and family were very impressed with how easy it was to glide on. I would recommend this product to others. It's wonderful!

👤I got an eyelid infection because of this eyeliner. It is better to spend a little more for a product that is manufactured in the US.

👤It's not easy to apply. Rub back and forth to get the color. IT Cosmetics is easy to apply with a light hand and is creamy with a lot of color.

👤It's hard to get them started.

👤They work great and the price is the same at the store.

4. Neutrogena Eyeliner Antioxidant Water Resistant Smooth Gliding

Neutrogena Eyeliner Antioxidant Water Resistant Smooth Gliding

Neutrogena's smokey gray eye liner is water resistant and will last for a long time. The smooth eyeliner is very easy to apply and it will appear instantly. This gray kohl eyeliner is smudgeable for the first 30 seconds, making it the perfect smokey eye. The long-wear eyeliner is smudge and flake resistant and creates a glamorous full eye effect with rich color that does not fade after drying. This smoky eye makeup is easy to apply and gentle on eyes.

Brand: Neutrogena

👤It smudges when I first put it on. It stays and doesn't smudge after the initial smudge. It could dry and not smudge if I didn't blink right away. I cover it with dark eyeshadow and rub it off. It stays in after that. That is good. I have eye allergies and watery eyes. This one is pretty good because my eyeliner usually smudges right off. I don't have to make it sharper. I have to turn the bottom to get the eyeliner up. Very nice!

👤Love it. This is the third time I have ordered it. I was unsure about the first time I ordered it, but now that I have used it, I would not want to be without it. It's easy to put on. It looks great.

👤To see if it's a real thing, send it to neutrogena.

👤I bought this because I use other eyeliner and don't have itchy eyes. I only used it twice. I had to go over the same spot multiple times. I only used it twice because my eyes started to get tired.

👤It is hard to wipe off smudges.

👤I love Neutrogena. Every item works as advertised. Neutrogena is a great purchase.

👤I was very pleased with this eyeliner. It came quickly and stayed on better than I expected.

5. Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof

Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof

The waterproof eyeliner pencil glides on smoothly for a smooth finish that lasts for 36 hours. This eyeliner has a precise definition, from classic black to bright white and every shade in between. It's all in the eyes, from the subtle lines to the smokey vibes, their eyeshadow, eyeliner, brows and mascara collections are designed to transform your look. Make eye looks with eyeshadows, brow pencils and eyeliners, and perfect your lips with lipsticks and lip balms. The number one makeup brand in the world is Maybelline, and it is Diverse, on the pulse, inspired by the city and tested on its streets.

Brand: Maybelline New York

👤This is a color that I love. I use it on my upper waterline and in my upper lash line and I am gone on the color, but I can't say enough about the formula and how it lasts. An alternative to black. I have been trying to move away from black because it seems so harsh on my pale skin. I was concerned that it would be a strange blue color and not a dark navy when it was on. The formula is creamy enough to go on smoothly, but not so creamy that your body heat makes it melt and travel into unwanted areas. I have seen in some of the reviews that people have trouble with it, but I use it occasionally to line the bottom lashes. I always use a small lip liner brush and translucent powder to set any liner I put under my eyes to avoid that kind of problem. Unless you use a liquid eyeliner that dries down fast, cream eyeliner is not going to travel when placed under the eye. It is just the nature of the beast and the oil production that has to occur there to protect that delicate skin. If you do use this eyeliner there, make sure to set it with a small amount of powder. The liner lasts all day, stays in place, and doesn't lose color even in the waterline. During a battle with my backyard and jungle on a 90 degree day, it survived high humidity and heat, and stayed in place during an 8-hour intense house cleaning session. This brand and formula is what I want.

👤It was not "glide on in one smooth stroke" first use, and it looked good, but it started to feel tacky and bothered my eyes, and when I checked, it was still tacky. It was terrible to take it off with a waterproof makeup removal product. My eyes hurt so bad that I got red. I had to go over it many times and it was all over my eye area. It was very frustrating. I tried to be very light handed and the same thing happened, I felt tacky on my eyes and when I looked in the mirror I had smudges under my eyes. The proof is SMUDGE PROOF. There is no waterproof. No, you have smudged eyes. It is easy to come off. No way! It was very hard to get off. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone. The only reason for 2 stars was because it looked good until it smudged and stayed on, and I had to deal with the smudges all day. I was checking my eyes all the time. It took about 15 minutes to get it off and a ton of eye makeup removal. Then washed my face with a makeup towelette. Very disappointed.

👤I have tried many brands and they all smudge, make me look like a vampire and leave me with dark gloomy eyes. The brand and line is the best. No smudge, waterproof, easy to apply, great color and no vampire eyes. I bought 3 colors at the same time.

6. SUPER STAY Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Essential

SUPER STAY Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Essential

The waterproof Super-Stay Liner comes in 21 highly pigmented shades and 3 beautiful finishes to fit your mood. Easy-glide Super-Stay Liner pencil has a non-smudge setting that allows for a softer or smokier look before it goes on creamy. A must-have beauty staple, this pencil eyeliner creates a perfect, full lash line or a playful, colored look that will last all day. The WUNDER2 pencil sharpener is sold separately. WUNDER2 makeup products are never tested on animals.

Brand: Wunder2

👤I have a drawer full of eye pencils. I have finally found a pencil that stays, so they are going to the garbage. I did my eyes two nights ago to see how long it would last. No smudges, runs, or black eyes. I am buying every color they have. I have very oily skin and have been looking for the perfect eye liner. Don't spend any more money on stores. You will not regret buying this pencil.

👤The problem is explained in my video. I'm stuck with eyeliner.

👤This is a 3.5 out of 5 on smudginess when compared to the other WATERPROOF/SMUDGEPROOF eyeliners I've tried. For waterproof-ness, 5 out of 5, and 0 out of 5 for sharpening ability. I use one of my pocket knives to cut it down after trying so many different techniques. I hate using eyeliner because it still snaps. It will smudge on bare skin just as easily. There is a smudge near the corners of my eyes after 40 minutes. I don't have time to check it every few hours. I've used several brands. The color is nice, but it's too much of a hassle to order again.

👤I have dry eye. I usually have one eye. Thanks to your liner, I now have liner all day. I love it!

👤The Essential Brown is a dark brown/black color and this is a good pencil. The right sharpener is important. I didn't rate it five stars because they shouldn't sell a sharpener. I had to buy three different sharpeners to find one that was thin enough to give the pencil a sharp point. It's best to keep this pencil out of the sun to avoid breaking the tip. I have only been wearing it for a few days and if I notice it running or making noise, I will change the review. I am 55 years old and I find it harder to find a liner that doesn't transfer when I sweat. You can'tsharpen this penCIL! Don't buy it. Even if refrigerated, the tip breaks off. I took it to a store that didn't have anyone who could sharpen it.

👤eyeliner falls off my lower eye as I age. It's true! I've tried near waterproof brands before. This one is the best so far. It felt like I had put glue to my eye. I held down the bottom skin until it dried. I tried rubbing it off and it didn't smudge. I had to apply makeup removal the next day. I applied it as soon as it arrived and by 11 pm it was gone from one eye to the other. I'm not sure if it was because I use drops in my eye, or if it was because it didn't cover me. If there are any changes, I'll update this review. I think it's great that you have to touch up your eyes once a day. The brown is similar to black.

👤The eye liner is waterproof. I have oily eye lids and waterproof liners that don't hold for more than 4-5 hours. This liner was on me all day. I thought the pencil was perfect for waterline, but not the best to shape the wing liner. It glides on smoothly, dry instantly, and the pigment lasts all day until you take it off with a waterproof makeup cleanser.

7. Urban Decay Glide Pencil Sabbath

Urban Decay Glide Pencil Sabbath

Urban Decay's waterproof eyeliner pencils deliver intense, long-wearing color that won't budge. Keep your eyeliner sharp with the Grind House Double Barrel Pencil Sharpener. There are five different finishes for their vibrant, stay-true shades. Sabbath has a deep navy finish. The creamy formula glides on smoothly so you can draw a precise line, but stays soft so you can smudge. This eyeliner will last all day for wear. There are ingredients for moisturiZing. The eyeliner is made with hydrating ingredients. Jojoba oil and cottonseed oil condition and soothe the skin. Play well with other people and pair your eyeliner pencil with their Eyeshadow Primer Potion to create a custom cream eyeshadow.

Brand: Urban Decay

👤I'm always mad at myself for buying things on Amazon. I needed to replace my Buxom Insider Eyeliner. I ordered two because I read that Urban Decay is the closest. The first arrived quickly. I removed the cap from the pencil and saw that it had been used. I wanted to return it quickly. I made it sanitary by sharpening it. The second pencil was used but worse than the first. I was not comfortable. It goes on the inside of your eyelid. Who wants to get sick there? The seller was very nice. The other two were in an open box, and the pencil I received in exchange was also in an open box. The cap was dirty and smudged like the others. The point of the pencil was pushed in when I removed the cap. I was not sure if it could be sharpened. I wrote to the seller again to make her aware. I did not ask to return it. It wasn't worth the risk of another trip toUPS for us because we're in a house that's been sealed off. I wanted to make the seller aware that it is not a good practice to resell returned eyeliner pencils. I did not ask for anything after I sent her a photo of the pushed in point. She said that her items are new and unused. I will try to avoid buying cosmetics on Amazon in the future since I know how it is. Eye infections are the worst.

👤I tested the eyeliners to see which ones I liked the most. The waterline of the eye is what I apply my eyeliner to. I wanted an eyeliner that wouldn't smudge and wouldn't make me look like an animal. I didn't find any that were perfect. The highest rating I gave was 4 stars, and there were three that fit that rating. The list is from my least favorites to the highest. The Eyeliner Test was rated 4 stars by me. I rated it 4 stars because it doesn't smudge, it's easy to use, and it's fairly well all day. End of Day: still present, but is a little too messy for me, but it's pretty good. Application: easy, but messy, only sticks to the dry skin of the eyelid. The Lasts were not End of Day, but they were smooth and easy to apply. The name is Intense i-color Color: Raisin Quartz 004 and it barely shows up when applied.

👤You sent a used pencil and it was disappointing. Not only used, but without a cap, with fuzz attached to the eyeliner and stained with a blue paint. The experience was frightening.

👤For over an hour, I worked with it. I don't want to "glide on" here. It was hard, but not really. $30 was wasted. The "glide on:" was a selling point for me, as my eyes are no longer smooth. Don't need a product that accentuates it.

👤I've been using a black eyeliner by the end of the evening since the 90's. This goes on smoothly and stays put for at least 8 hours. It does what it says, but it's so soft it doesn't keep a point or stay sharp for long, so you can't really get a fine line. It's worth it.

8. Eyeliner Waterproof Eyebrow Cosmetics Sharpene

Eyeliner Waterproof Eyebrow Cosmetics Sharpene

High quality, long lasting Eyeliner Pencil is available in 12 different colors. All are brand new. It is possible to smudge out naturally with super waterproof eyeliner. The canned form is a slashable pen type, which makes it easy to use. Soft core, hard texture, strong stretch performance, can draw a detailed eyeliner, not blooming. It can be used as a lip liner and lipstick. One line is needed to draw the outliner. Show the color of lipstick. The paragraph is a must have.

Brand: Dc-beautiful

👤These pencils are really cool. I thought I was too old to use these colors. They look great. My granddaughters love to give me makeovers with these colored pencils. Love them.

👤These are great for makeup. The color stays on for a good amount of time after sharpening. I was very happy with the purchase.

👤Very bright. Excellent product for an awesome piece. Will be buying again.

👤Eyeliners are terrible. It's very difficult to transfer to the eyelid. Had to use a lighter. Do not recommend.

👤I use baby blue eyeliner and have not been able to find much recently. I love the baby blue that this one has. I have used some of the other colors as well. Goes on smooth and stays put.

👤I love these eyeshadow pencils. The colors glide on smoothly. They smudged when I rubbed them, but that is what I wanted them to do, since they are for eyeshadow. I can't speak on longevity because I haven't worn any yet. I am happy with my purchase. When these run low, I will purchase them again. Thanks!

👤I love these. I didn't think they would be so great for such a low price. It is easy to apply fun colors. I'm having fun with it. There are lips, eyes, and eyebrows.

👤The wear on these is better than I expected. They work well as lip liners. The package came with a sharpner. The colors are bold.

9. NYX Mechanical Pencil Gypsy Blue

NYX Mechanical Pencil Gypsy Blue

A line and defined eye is just a twist away with this eyeliner pen, and Intense pigment covers like a liquid eyeliner, while its creamy formula holds for hours, and no need to sharpen just twist up and apply for a winged out eyeliner look. The smudge proof eyeliner glides on easily and lasts all day through heat and humidity, no sad bleeding eyeliner here, and is available in natural to bright shades. All Eyes On Eye Makeup includes NYX Professional Makeup eye makeup products from eyeshadow to mascara, eyeliners, and setting sprays. They don't test their products on animals, and they believe animals belong in their arms, not in a lab. NYX Professional Makeup has a wide range of makeup and beauty products, from eyeshadow, eyeliner, mascara and false lashes to lipstick, foundation, primer, blush, bronzer, brushes and more.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤I have noticed that the skin on my eyelid is a bit tighter than it used to be, and the eye pencils I used to use don't go on as smoothly as they used to. The NYX mechanical eye pencils are as smooth as silk. If you want something precise, this isn't it. It stays on all day. I only had one pencil that twisted out about a quarter of an inch before the mechanism got stuck, but it didn't bother me because of the low cost and high performance. If I have an occasional dud with this brand, it's still worth it because I'm used to using MAC and Clinique pencils.

👤I can smudge it the way I need it to get that smokey eyes effect, and it's easy to put on waterline.

👤The best eyeliner ever. I don't know why or how, but this shade of eyeliner is the only eyeliner I can wear all around my eye and it's flattering. I have been using it for 3 years. This liner is in Bronze.

👤The eye liner I bought lasts all day and is white. I used the pencil on my waterline because I have small eyes and it stayed on all day. The eye liner does not irritate the eyes.

👤I'm terrible at applying eyeliner, so this was a lifesaver. It's creamy, so it doesn't bother you when you apply it, but it dries out in a minute or so, so it lasts all day. If I want a darker look, I apply black or navy eyeliner and then apply this on top, it smooths over the shakiness of the dark eyeliner, and looks a whole lot more interesting. It's light and looks a bit like metallic eyeshadow if you smudge it, but still appropriate for wearing to class or going to work. I used to use a liquid eye shadow from Glossier, but it didn't work as well as I would have liked, and it fades quickly. It comes off easily with a wipe or miscellar water even though it stays on for 10 hours. It's great if you want to cover mistakes or simply as a stand-in so you don't have to tell the world what you're doing. I plan to buy gold and blue as well. You can find this product at Bed, Bath + Beyond or any other store.

👤I've bought a lot of white eye liners in the last few years trying to find one that stayed on my lower water line. I tried this one out while I was working in the house to see if it would perform better than any of the others that I had spent money on. This is very easy to apply and stays on the water line. I wiped it out of the corners near the tear ducts because I was working and sweating here in the house, but it stayed where I put it for the entire afternoon and evening. It did fade slightly later but it did not do as well as I had hoped. Depending on your work environment, a single application of this would probably last through an entire evening function or most of a work day. It makes the eyes pop. I highly recommend either putting this on before mascara or putting an extra coat on after applying it to the water line. It is very creamy and will stick to the base of the lashes along the water line, so it needs to be covered over to avoid black lashes. This is a great product and I highly recommend it and am very happy to have finally found one after five attempts with other brands, that not only shows up really well, but stays put. I was reminded to write a review now that I was about to order two more. Mrs. Yvonne Hancock is a woman.

10. Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

All day long, use Eyeliner Ocean Blue and it will stay put for at least 10 hours on your top or bottom lashes. This eyeliner pencil glides smoothly on your lashes and sets for a long- lasting finish that's been tested for 10 hours of wear. This gel eyeliner is made with a special wax blend that ensures color glides on gently without tugging or skipping. It works well for both top lashes and your inner waterline. The high- performance pigments give a bold color payoff all day long. The unique formula combines the ease of a regular eyeliner pencil with the smoothness of a gel eyeliner, so you'll get perfect, vibrant color in a single swiped. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. How to apply? It's safe for the waterline and you can glide this gel eyeliner pencil easily. Do you want a smoky finish? Smudge gently with your fingers or a brush.

Brand: Julep

👤The gel pencil stays put all day. It took me a while to figure out that you can use a pencil sharpener to sharpen this, even though you are not using wood. It does work, but you might need to clean the blades with alcohol if they get gummed up, and if you find the pencil spinning without sharpening. Try putting the pencil in the freezer for an hour.

👤The struggle is real and I have a makeup addiction. I'm an equal opportunity makeup nerd, I have everything from bargain to luxury cosmetics. I have very sensitive eyes and I need to be very careful when selecting eye products that contain glitter or shine. I gave it a try in the hopes that it would work for me. The Julep "When Pencil Met Gel" Long Lasting Gel Eyeliner is a medium sized pencil. It glides on smoothly and is easy to smudge or blend if done immediately, so it's important to smudge it upon application. I have dry eyes. I didn't have any problems with applying this. The liner was put in place all day. The shade is shimmery, not overly shiny, but it's enough to make my eyes brighter. It's very pretty and has become my go to liner for everyday wear. It's similar to the Stila 24 Hour eyeliner pencil but less expensive. This is my first Julep purchase, but it won't be my last. It's a lovely formula. I'm very impressed!

👤I have tried many waterproof eyeliner pencils over the years and this one is by far the best. The pencil does not break when it is sharpened. The infused gel allows for a smooth gliding application without tugging at delicate eye tissue. The eyeliner stays on all day. It comes in my favorite color, forest green, which makes my hazel eyes brighter. I hope that this product will be around for a long time since it is difficult to find superior makeup.

👤This eyeliner was too dark for my skin tone and age. It was easy to apply for me. I was hoping for a little more light plum, but it lasted all day and I used it lightly. It was too harsh for a lady my age. I'll either stick to the right colors or look for a lighter shade of plum. My granddaughters will be happy to use this. It will not go to waste. There is no picture submitted at this time.

👤I've been looking for makeup brands that are vegan, cruelty-free and made with clean ingredients, and that care about the environment. It seemed like it would fit my criteria after reading so many positive reviews. The eyeliner was easy to apply. The eyeliner created a "racoon effect" within a couple hours of wear, and had faded from where I had applied it. The longevity of wear was not good. The product fell out of the tube when I opened it. There's only about an inch of product. The pencil tube is plastic. You can't move the product up or down as it wears down. This pencil is not very useful. I'm disappointed by how careless and wasteful products have become. It's obvious that companies care more about making money and creating disposable waste than they do about making thoughtful products that don't add to the burden on the earth. I'm giving money to companies that care. Don't spend your money on a product.

11. SUPER STAY Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Essential

SUPER STAY Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Essential

The waterproof Super-Stay Liner comes in 21 highly pigmented shades and 3 beautiful finishes to fit your mood. Easy-glide Super-Stay Liner pencil has a non-smudge setting that allows for a softer or smokier look before it goes on creamy. A must-have beauty staple, this pencil eyeliner creates a perfect, full lash line or a playful, colored look that will last all day. The WUNDER2 pencil sharpener is sold separately. WUNDER2 makeup products are never tested on animals.

Brand: Wunder2

👤I have a drawer full of eye pencils. I have finally found a pencil that stays, so they are going to the garbage. I did my eyes two nights ago to see how long it would last. No smudges, runs, or black eyes. I am buying every color they have. I have very oily skin and have been looking for the perfect eye liner. Don't spend any more money on stores. You will not regret buying this pencil.

👤The problem is explained in my video. I'm stuck with eyeliner.

👤This is a 3.5 out of 5 on smudginess when compared to the other WATERPROOF/SMUDGEPROOF eyeliners I've tried. For waterproof-ness, 5 out of 5, and 0 out of 5 for sharpening ability. I use one of my pocket knives to cut it down after trying so many different techniques. I hate using eyeliner because it still snaps. It will smudge on bare skin just as easily. There is a smudge near the corners of my eyes after 40 minutes. I don't have time to check it every few hours. I've used several brands. The color is nice, but it's too much of a hassle to order again.

👤I have dry eye. I usually have one eye. Thanks to your liner, I now have liner all day. I love it!

👤The Essential Brown is a dark brown/black color and this is a good pencil. The right sharpener is important. I didn't rate it five stars because they shouldn't sell a sharpener. I had to buy three different sharpeners to find one that was thin enough to give the pencil a sharp point. It's best to keep this pencil out of the sun to avoid breaking the tip. I have only been wearing it for a few days and if I notice it running or making noise, I will change the review. I am 55 years old and I find it harder to find a liner that doesn't transfer when I sweat. You can'tsharpen this penCIL! Don't buy it. Even if refrigerated, the tip breaks off. I took it to a store that didn't have anyone who could sharpen it.

👤eyeliner falls off my lower eye as I age. It's true! I've tried near waterproof brands before. This one is the best so far. It felt like I had put glue to my eye. I held down the bottom skin until it dried. I tried rubbing it off and it didn't smudge. I had to apply makeup removal the next day. I applied it as soon as it arrived and by 11 pm it was gone from one eye to the other. I'm not sure if it was because I use drops in my eye, or if it was because it didn't cover me. If there are any changes, I'll update this review. I think it's great that you have to touch up your eyes once a day. The brown is similar to black.

👤The eye liner is waterproof. I have oily eye lids and waterproof liners that don't hold for more than 4-5 hours. This liner was on me all day. I thought the pencil was perfect for waterline, but not the best to shape the wing liner. It glides on smoothly, dry instantly, and the pigment lasts all day until you take it off with a waterproof makeup cleanser.

Summary

What is the best product for eye liners for women pencil blue?

Eye liners for women pencil blue products from Rimmel. In this article about eye liners for women pencil blue you can see why people choose the product. Marcelle and Superthinker are also good brands to look for when you are finding eye liners for women pencil blue.

What are the best brands for eye liners for women pencil blue?

Rimmel, Marcelle and Superthinker are some of the best brands that chosen by people for eye liners for women pencil blue. Find the detail in this article. Neutrogena, Maybelline New York and Wunder2 are also brands that their products are worth to check.

You May Like

Share Your Story

Your name:
Choose product to comment:
Write your review:
By submitting this review, you are agree that:
  • Your review is based on fact, honest, polite and not harmful to anyone or any brands.
  • We have full right to show or not-to-show your review after moderation.
  • No spamm please :)
Disclaimer
We might earn comission for your shopping via our links, it doesn't cost you extra. This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com