Best Eye Liners for Women Pencil Brown

Women 8 Oct 2022 10+ Comments Open

1. NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Brown

NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Brown

A line and defined eye is just a twist away with this eyeliner pen. The creamy formula holds for hours while the intense color covers. It's not necessary to apply twist-up and eyeliner for a winged-out look. SMUDGE-PROOF & SMOOTH: This smudge-proof eyeliner glides on easily and lasts all day through heat and humidity. Their Retractable Eye Pencil is available in natural to bright shades. Eye makeup for the perfect POP is just one of the many things to look for. Their complete line of eye makeup includes eyeshadow singles and palettes, false lashes, mascara, liquid eyeliner and eyebrow pencils. It is free of contraceptives. They don't think animals belong in a lab. All of their makeup is vegan. They don't test their products on animals. Discover New York professional makeup. Try all of their pro makeup and beauty products.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤I have noticed that the skin on my eyelid is a bit tighter than it used to be, and the eye pencils I used to use don't go on as smoothly as they used to. The NYX mechanical eye pencils are as smooth as silk. If you want something precise, this isn't it. It stays on all day. I only had one pencil that twisted out about a quarter of an inch before the mechanism got stuck, but it didn't bother me because of the low cost and high performance. If I have an occasional dud with this brand, it's still worth it because I'm used to using MAC and Clinique pencils.

👤I can smudge it the way I need it to get that smokey eyes effect, and it's easy to put on waterline.

👤The best eyeliner ever. I don't know why or how, but this shade of eyeliner is the only eyeliner I can wear all around my eye and it's flattering. I have been using it for 3 years. This liner is in Bronze.

👤The eye liner I bought lasts all day and is white. I used the pencil on my waterline because I have small eyes and it stayed on all day. The eye liner does not irritate the eyes.

👤I'm terrible at applying eyeliner, so this was a lifesaver. It's creamy, so it doesn't bother you when you apply it, but it dries out in a minute or so, so it lasts all day. If I want a darker look, I apply black or navy eyeliner and then apply this on top, it smooths over the shakiness of the dark eyeliner, and looks a whole lot more interesting. It's light and looks a bit like metallic eyeshadow if you smudge it, but still appropriate for wearing to class or going to work. I used to use a liquid eye shadow from Glossier, but it didn't work as well as I would have liked, and it fades quickly. It comes off easily with a wipe or miscellar water even though it stays on for 10 hours. It's great if you want to cover mistakes or simply as a stand-in so you don't have to tell the world what you're doing. I plan to buy gold and blue as well. You can find this product at Bed, Bath + Beyond or any other store.

👤I've bought a lot of white eye liners in the last few years trying to find one that stayed on my lower water line. I tried this one out while I was working in the house to see if it would perform better than any of the others that I had spent money on. This is very easy to apply and stays on the water line. I wiped it out of the corners near the tear ducts because I was working and sweating here in the house, but it stayed where I put it for the entire afternoon and evening. It did fade slightly later but it did not do as well as I had hoped. Depending on your work environment, a single application of this would probably last through an entire evening function or most of a work day. It makes the eyes pop. I highly recommend either putting this on before mascara or putting an extra coat on after applying it to the water line. It is very creamy and will stick to the base of the lashes along the water line, so it needs to be covered over to avoid black lashes. This is a great product and I highly recommend it and am very happy to have finally found one after five attempts with other brands, that not only shows up really well, but stays put. I was reminded to write a review now that I was about to order two more. Mrs. Yvonne Hancock is a woman.

2. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil Brown

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil Brown

With SoftFlex ComFort Technology you can shape and define your eyes. The fine line of intense color wears up to 16 hours. The Color Stay waterproof formula won't smudge or be smudged off. There is a built-in sharpener.

Brand: Revlon

👤I have used this for many years and it is smudge free and waterproof. Even when I am sweaty. Doesn't seem to fade. If I leave the pencil without a lid for a few hours, it becomes dry and brittle and will break. And becomes useless. I have been foolish enough to buy again and again. I don't know anything else that would work. I think that whatever formula is used to make it long lasting causes it to dry very fast and become brittle. I wish that Revlon will improve the quality. I will stick to this product. I will seal it tight after use.

👤I bought this to find something that wouldn't ruin my eyes. I am 53 years old and the lines are starting to show. I only put eye liner under my lashes because I have contacts. It goes on easy and it has a little smudgy thing on the end, but after about an hour it has turned into a raccoon look under my eyes that is almost impossible to get rid of without washing your face first. I will keep searching.

👤I have used this brand before and it is a great brow/liner. Had to purchase online due to the flu. I love this pencil, but it was useless. Purchasing from a store.

👤The pencil does not line easily. It's a struggle and I'm very disappointed. Would not recommend it. I threw it away.

👤Excellent eyeliner, especially for the money. It stays on well and goes on without any problems. I've paid more for eyeliners that weren't good.

👤I only tried it once and then bought two more. It stays on all day because they work great. Don't be sorry if you try it.

👤The product is easy to apply and can last for over five hours. It is reliable and serves its purpose, even though it is not a luxury brand.

👤Doesn't pull, goes on smoothly. There was no rubbing or fade on my crease or upper lid. I buy at least two at a time.

3. Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

All day long, wear eye liner, use eye liner sharpener for full use. It will stay on your top or bottom lashes for at least 10 hours and is safe for waterlines. This eyeliner pencil glides smoothly on your lashes and sets for a long- lasting finish that's been tested for 10 hours of wear. This gel eyeliner is made with a special wax blend that ensures color glides on gently without tugging or skipping. It works well for both top lashes and your inner waterline. The high- performance pigments give a bold color payoff all day long. The unique formula combines the ease of a regular eyeliner pencil with the smoothness of a gel eyeliner, so you'll get perfect, vibrant color in a single swiped. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. Over twenty-four hours of mat and smimmer. The formula combines the ease of a regular eyeliner pencil with the smoothness of a gel eyeliner, so you'll get perfect, vibrant color in a single stroke. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. How to apply? It's safe for the waterline and you can glide this gel eyeliner pencil easily. Do you want a smoky finish? Smudge gently with your fingers or a brush.

Brand: Julep

👤The gel pencil stays put all day. It took me a while to figure out that you can use a pencil sharpener to sharpen this, even though you are not using wood. It does work, but you might need to clean the blades with alcohol if they get gummed up, and if you find the pencil spinning without sharpening. Try putting the pencil in the freezer for an hour.

👤The struggle is real and I have a makeup addiction. I'm an equal opportunity makeup nerd, I have everything from bargain to luxury cosmetics. I have very sensitive eyes and I need to be very careful when selecting eye products that contain glitter or shine. I gave it a try in the hopes that it would work for me. The Julep "When Pencil Met Gel" Long Lasting Gel Eyeliner is a medium sized pencil. It glides on smoothly and is easy to smudge or blend if done immediately, so it's important to smudge it upon application. I have dry eyes. I didn't have any problems with applying this. The liner was put in place all day. The shade is shimmery, not overly shiny, but it's enough to make my eyes brighter. It's very pretty and has become my go to liner for everyday wear. It's similar to the Stila 24 Hour eyeliner pencil but less expensive. This is my first Julep purchase, but it won't be my last. It's a lovely formula. I'm very impressed!

👤I have tried many waterproof eyeliner pencils over the years and this one is by far the best. The pencil does not break when it is sharpened. The infused gel allows for a smooth gliding application without tugging at delicate eye tissue. The eyeliner stays on all day. It comes in my favorite color, forest green, which makes my hazel eyes brighter. I hope that this product will be around for a long time since it is difficult to find superior makeup.

👤This eyeliner was too dark for my skin tone and age. It was easy to apply for me. I was hoping for a little more light plum, but it lasted all day and I used it lightly. It was too harsh for a lady my age. I'll either stick to the right colors or look for a lighter shade of plum. My granddaughters will be happy to use this. It will not go to waste. There is no picture submitted at this time.

👤I've been looking for makeup brands that are vegan, cruelty-free and made with clean ingredients, and that care about the environment. It seemed like it would fit my criteria after reading so many positive reviews. The eyeliner was easy to apply. The eyeliner created a "racoon effect" within a couple hours of wear, and had faded from where I had applied it. The longevity of wear was not good. The product fell out of the tube when I opened it. There's only about an inch of product. The pencil tube is plastic. You can't move the product up or down as it wears down. This pencil is not very useful. I'm disappointed by how careless and wasteful products have become. It's obvious that companies care more about making money and creating disposable waste than they do about making thoughtful products that don't add to the burden on the earth. I'm giving money to companies that care. Don't spend your money on a product.

4. LOreal Paris Self Advancing Eyeliner Expresso

LOreal Paris Self Advancing Eyeliner Expresso

The eyeliner formula is smooth. It is easy to eyeliner glides on for precise lines. Eye liner for sensitive eyes. Smudge-Proof eyeliner.

Brand: L'oreal Paris

👤I have been using this eyeliner for over 9 years. I haven't found one that goes on as smooth as this, doesn't smudge easily, or runs if I'm sweating. The glide-on is perfect. I like that I can just roll the eyeliner up when I need more. I have tried many other eyeliners when this one has sold out, but haven't fallen in love with any. I own this one. I highly recommend.

👤I've tried a lot of different pencils and nothing works as well as this. It is easy to use and a definite buy for me. Smudging is very easy if you like it. I have oily skin and this stays where I put it. I take my makeup off with Noxema and then any type of Best product on the market. If you like that look, it is easy to do without a beard. I've tried many brands including Bare Minerals. This is nothing compared to this. A definite purchase.

👤I've tried every eyeliner available from cheap to most expensive, including powders, liquid and pencils that roll up or you have to sharpen them. I can't make a continuous line because my skin has aged. All other eye liners had to fill in little age lines without causing a jagged line. I bought ELF eye primer after reading the reviews. The liner stayed put for about 10 hours. It was very easy to line the upper eyelid. I wasted a lot of time with other products. If you use an angle eyeliner brush, you can smooth your eyeliner without smudges.

👤Bell's palsy makes my right eye very dry. I have seasonal allergies. I've tried many eyeliners and this one stays in place. People with similar issues should be recommended by me. You get great value for your money.

👤I needed to buy this because I love my brown lipsticks. I use this color with my Loreal Colour Riche - Cutting Edge Cork color and it looks great! Even after eating lunch, the lip liner stays on. It still looks decent, but I have to fix it a bit in the afternoon. It helps with the bleeding of lipstick on your lips. I recommend putting some loose powder around your lips to help with the bleeding.

👤I like the color of this pencil, but it requires frequent reapplying throughout the day. I'm not reordering it because it smudges easily.

👤I only used up a few weeks after I bought it. I like the way it ends. I ordered it because I thought the first one might have been faulty. The same thing happened. They don't put a lot of product in the pen. If you only use it a few times a year, it may last a few days, but it's a waste of plastic, paper and shipping for something that you have to keep reordering every two weeks.

👤I give it 3 stars because it's not "water/run-proof" and it smudges in embarrassing proportions. I use it on the inside of my eye and it wears off in 30 minutes, but I have to use lotion to clean the smudge underneath and around my eyes. It doesn't stay on as long as I would like because it would be a perfect eyeliner. It is a dark black and goes on so smooth that it is great. Other eyeliners are hard to put on and hurt my eyes trying to put it on. This one is very intense. If you're not looking for something that will last all day, this is fine. If you only want eyeliner for a short time. This is the one that you can easily take off from.

5. Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil Black

Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil Black

Waterproof eye liner: long wear. Their cult-classic, longwear pencil eyeliner has a waterproof formula that lasts up to 24 hours and has a smooth, creamy glide. Up to 24 hour wear. The eyeliner stays put for up to 24 hours for smudge-proof looks that stay with you all day. A built-in sharpener and smudger are included to make your eyes look smoldering and smoky. A multitude of eyeliner looks can be created from defined to dramatic, winged liner, cat eye liner, and more. There are 8 eye-tested shades. That glides on smooth.

Brand: Revlon

👤I've ordered it from Amazon a few times and it hasn't worked out. The product came in good condition once. The tip of the pencil breaks off easily. I was good to go, I would just sharpen it a little with the built in sharpener. The most recent time that I ordered from here, it was terrible. The pencil broke easily. I thought there was a metal rod in the middle of the crumbled outer layers because they were so hard. The pencil had a foul odor and that signals to me that the pencil has expired. I used eyeliner because I needed it, but it irritated my eyes. It's not a good idea to use expired makeup. The pencil should be good, but you should buy it from your local drugstore.

👤I tried a set of new ones, but they still break off. I don't know if you're going to try to make them sharper. It made them worse. I've ordered 4 pencils with the same results. I tried to roll up the color, but it didn't work, so it's a shame. The pencils are a pretty color. I would love to send them back. I can't. I paid a lot of money for them. I would take a different type of pencil. I would like my money back.

👤I've been using the Colorstay Eyeliner for over a decade. The product quality is terrible, but I was excited by the lower price. The eyeliner does not go on smoothly, it keeps breaking off, and it's difficult to sharpen because it keeps breaking off. It has been very wasteful and frustrating. I've never had a problem with this product before. Is this a bad batches? I went through 9 or 10 and all of them were bad. I'm very sad.

👤This product has been my favorite for a long time. I think 6. I was not happy with my last order. I threw away my eyeliner after I tried to apply it and it broke all the way down, barely being able to use any before it broke completely. It was a really sad thing. I've loved it for a long time, so I'm not sure why this happened.

👤A lot of people use this for their eyes, but I use it as my eyebrow pencil. It is long lasting and doesn't fade. The pencil is popular in darker colors and it was starting to become a nuisance to buy it in the store. They sell this on Amazon. It should be me for awhile because I purchase about 5 of them. I pencil my eyebrows in with this pencil every day and it lasts about two weeks to a month.

👤I have been using this eyeliner for a long time. I've tried many brands and nothing compares. I don't like to apply makeup all day long and my eyes tend to get oily. This lasts! It doesn't bleed. Don't waste your money on more expensive brands, it's an eyeliner...not a shirt. No one will know if it's a drugstore or Christian Dior. You can save money on clothes, shoes, and accessories. The beauty of makeup.

6. Pencil Black Brown Cosmetics Spe931

Pencil Black Brown Cosmetics Spe931

Slim, trim, but never prim, their Slim Eye Pencils come in a variety of shades. This eye liner formula is long-wearing and creamy. All Eyes On Eye Makeup includes NYX Professional Makeup eye makeup products from eyeshadow to mascara, eyeliners, and setting sprays. They don't test their products on animals, and they believe animals belong in their arms, not in a lab. NYX Professional Makeup has a wide range of makeup and beauty products, from eyeshadow, eyeliner, mascara and false lashes to lipstick, foundation, primer, blush, bronzer, brushes and more.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤It's a good color to go with my Covid white hair. It is easy to sharpen. Every other wooden brow pencil I've used, you occasionally get bad wood, that either sharpens badly on one side, or has bad grain, and the pencil disappears in one sharpening. Some pencils have brittle lead inside and break off when you sharpen them. I've used the NYX ones for a long time and haven't had a bad one yet.

👤My husband can finally see in bold. My brows are angry when he is upset.

👤The makeup was vacuum wrapped with a plastic that kept it sanitary and clean when it arrived. It was a beautiful bright blue and it was easy to do. I didn't need any pressure on my water line or pencil. It was bought in two other colors. Would definitely recommend.

👤I have had it for a couple of years. It is only 3 inches long but it works. It glides on and stays on until you wash it off. The one I bought from Amazon was terrible. When you put it on, it smudges, but it is not black. It's not as dark as it could be.

👤I have no eyebrows, so I use this pencil for them. I have tried many pencils, but this one has worked better than any of them. It lasts all day.

👤This product is useless. To make a mark on the skin, one must bear down with more force than is possible on the face. The results are not very good. I would rate this pencil with no stars. Don't waste your money!

👤I replaced my eyeliner pencil with this pencil. I have used the covergirl taupe for years and it is very hard to find one like it. I don't want to use the CoverGirl pencil anymore because it has parabens in it. It's a great color for my bottom line. The other pencils that say they're taupe are not. I thought I had found the perfect one, but it was red. It's not as red as some of the others, but it's enough for me to notice. I'll keep this one, but I'll stop. I'll be looking for a pencil that won't have red on it. The NYX pencil is harder than the CoverGirl one so it does not apply very easily. I have to warm it up. I applied it after running it under hot water. The top and bottom of the picture are the same item, the NYX taupe pencil. It will do for now, but not again.

👤I like a lighter shade of brown eyeliner that doesn't affect my light complexion, so I bought the shade taupe. The lower lashes don't give the best color payoff. I barely could see the product when I pressed hard. I used it as a brow product because it's a flattering shade of brown that matches my eyebrows and I also like it on my upper lashes. It's a great eyeliner, even though it has occasional lack of reliability.

7. Physicians Formula Booster Boosting Eyeliner

Physicians Formula Booster Boosting Eyeliner

LIQUID EYELINER AND EYELASH SERUM: This formula works beautifully as a LIQUID eyeliner and also delivers Lash boosting complex to the base of eyelashes, where it enhances the look of lashes while hydrating and conditioning. PHYSICIAN'S FORMULA EYE LINER. Their eyeliner pens and eyeliner pencils are safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. They glide on smoothly for a defined eye. Physician's Formula has everything you need to draw eyes, from their eye enhancing eyeshadow pallet and eyelash eyeliners, to their Eye Boosters and 2-in-1 eyeliner and eye primer. Physician's Formula has a full line of makeup and skin care for sensitive skin. Their products are safe for sensitive skin and eyes. Beauty products that are healthy. All of their products are safe for sensitive skin and eyes, and are created without any of the harsh ingredients found in other personal care items.

Brand: Physicians Formula

👤Even if the ink runs out, you can still get that line of perfect eyeliner by dipping the pen into a liquid or powder eyeshadow. If the eyeliner runs dry, you can wet it to bring it back to life.

👤A great tip for applying a thin line. I think one application a day is the best way to go about it. If I go out in the evening, I might touch up the lower line if I have been outside in hot weather. If you need a little more liquid to be released, I have found that just lightly stroking the Q-Tip will get the liquid flowing again without shaking. After trying many eye liners, I have found this to be the best. I highly recommend it.

👤I swear by this eyeliner. I've used a lot of expensive eyeliners and I always come back to this baby. I have oily eyes and usually things that work for one do not work for the other. My eyes are irritated if my oily lids don't smudge. If it doesn't bother me, then it's all over the place within a couple hours. Not this stuff! I put it on in the morning for work and had it last through a night of drinking and dancing. The tip of the applicator is more like a synthetic brush than a felt tip liner. It's so small and perfect that even someone sloppy like me can get a perfect line. I can't think of a single eyeliner that could compete with this one for me.

👤I thought this was the best I had ever used. I got a couple of weeks out of it and it was empty. I had the same issue after buying another one. The formula is easy to apply and doesn't smudge. If you use it daily, you should get a second because running out before you do the other eye is more annoying. It's really bad.

👤Physician's formula works as advertised, goes on easy, not thick or thin, also helps grow you eyelashes, which is a nice bonus. I use this liner with my favorite for perfect looking eyes. You won't be sorry if you try these.

👤This is the best liquid liners I've used. The brush is even better than the photo, it goes to a really fine point so you can get closer to the lashes than any other liner I've tried. Definitely recommend!

👤I have sensitive eyes and skin and this eyeliner doesn't bother me at all, it's the perfect color brown, and it's the exact right thickness.

👤Been using this item for a while. It helps with eye lashes.

👤Absolutely love it and order again. It does the job even though it isn't as bright as professional eyeliners. It's easy to remove and light for everyday use. I can go without even mascara because my lower lashes are longer, I am so happy with the results. Absolutely love it.

👤I've been using eyeliner for 15 years and have tried many different types. The tip of this eyeliner is very precise. When I apply it at the inner corner of my eye, I end up with a big blob of black in my eye because my eye waters a little. I have never used any other eyeliner that did that to me. I wonder if something in this formula is causing my eyes to water when I apply eyeliner. It is surprising to see how it is dispersed at a small amount of water. The liner is not the lightest black but it does become jet black after a few strokes. I don't have any problems with my eyeliners not staying put because I use eyeshadow primer and it lasts all day. Setting spray ruins this liner. I've begun applying setting spray before I apply my eyeliner. It will ruin the sharp lines I created if it does the weird running off thing. The product mentions that it has lash boosting properties. I've been using it for at least a month. I don't see a difference in my lashes. On a good day, I can achieve a really sharp cat eye look with this. It's impossible to achieve the look I want when my eyes tear, so I have to use other liquid liner in conjunction with this. I might buy it again because of it's precision. I'm looking for different liners.

8. Evpct Eyeliner Seconds Waterproof Colorful

Evpct Eyeliner Seconds Waterproof Colorful

It is a perfect package for a birthday gift. It's perfect for a lot of occasions, such as dating, party, wedding, bar, ball, camping, office, school, or daily makeups. The Winged Eyeliner Stamp is a perfect makeup accessory. Line up the stamp from the corner of your eye to the end of your eyebrow to create the same wing on each side. The perfect cat-eye is achieved by it. Wings are the best part of your makeup routine. It is easy to apply and clean, and also easy to remove, fast and clean. It is waterproof. The pen has 2 ends. One end for stamp and the other for defining the rest of the eye has a very fine tip. The size of the liner can be used as a stencil. Please check the color number on the top of the cover or the bottom of the outer box for any questions.

Brand: Evpct

👤The green and pink are pretty light, but they stay on well. It is worth the price. After an 8 hour work day, each of my pics was taken.

👤I wish I'd listened because this is exactly what they are. I took a photo of the pink from this set and the black from The Flick Stick brand, and it was obvious that the pink was different. This is not usable. It's so watery that you can't apply it, it doesn't dry and it wipes off right away.

👤This product was not good. It was difficult to remove the cap from the liners. The cap went off when I got it off the blue liner. I tried to find it. There were blue marks on my bathroom floor. The table was next to the fallen cartridge. I stepped on it and it moved to my floor. It dries out quickly, like in a month. The colors don't match up. I had a mild allergic reaction when I dug out the black one. I like the shape of the stamp. This product is not useful for me.

👤This product made my mornings easier. I can make a wingtip in fun colors like purple and green, black and brown, and hurry on out the door. It lasts until I take it off. I'm more than happy.

👤Don't buy this product. They are the same as Crayola markers in eyeliner form. When I tried them on my hand, I almost laughed. I chuckled a little. I received the wrong product after placing my order. They sent me the right product and were nice about it, but it took a couple of weeks to correct their issue. You should head to Target and buy some markers for what this product is. A costume item is definitely the best. Don't waste time or money.

👤The concept of these is lovely, but there are a few major cons for me. The other colors were very watery and feathered immediately, even though the purple eyeliner acted like normal liquid eyeliner. 2. The purple and brown look very dark on me. 3. The purple is the only usable one on me, and it does oxidize once dry. I'm part Italian and have all of the Mediterranean genes, so the feathering issue might be an issue of my oil-prone skin, and maybe the colors are darker because of my skin tone. I'm not sure. If you're light-skinned, you might only get the nice color effect. The pros are 1. There isn't any transfer to my brow bone because the purple sets up fast. 2. These are water resistant once dry, but still come off with a microfiber towel and water.

👤I was hoping to love this product but it leaked all over my hands and sink. I put it on. The liner was wet. The mess occurred when I shook it to get it to work. It took forever to clean up the mess since it's waterproof. I can't recommend because of the mess. I'm going to try another brand.

9. Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner Brown

Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner Brown

Their brown eyeliner is specially formulated for your delicate eye area and will compliment your natural eye color. Natural origin ingredients include Jojoba, Meadowfoam Seed and Mango oil. It is easy to apply. It's safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, and it's easy to apply to upper or lower lashes. Eyeliner penCIL: Soft Black, Midnight Gray and Warm Brown eyeliners are available in three different shades. Natural makeup. This eye pencil is made without synthetic fragrances or chemicals. Not tested on animals.

Brand: Burt's Bees

👤If you prefer pencil to liquid-style eyeliners and have extra sensitive eyelids, you should check out the Nourishing Eyeliners from Burt's Bees. Many eyeliners feel hard. Some eyeliners may be softer but may cause more tears and red eyes. Pencil eyeliners can wear away quickly. It is easy to apply and long- lasting. I am very pleased with the warm brown and black eyeliners that I have purchased.

👤I generally like the products from the Bees but on the eyeliners they need to go back to the drawing board. You can actually get them to apply to your eyes when they are smeared. The advertised colors apply more slowly than the lighter colors. I would have to give these eyeliners a thumbs down until they improved their formula.

👤When I sharpened my electric pencil sharpener, it had jagged edges that wouldn't be fixed by a mount of peeling or smoothing, even though I like the fact that it's cruelty free. It was too dangerous to use after that. It went into the trash. Lesson learned. I will not purchase this style of eye liner again.

👤I like this eye pencil. I realized that I needed to pay attention to what goes into my cosmetics. This is safe and performs perfectly. The skin around my eyes is soft and smooth. It provides a perfect line and when I want a smoky eye, it smudges nicely with my smudge sponge. It washes off easily at night. It's the only eye pencil I will use.

👤It's perfect that Burt's Bees Grey Eyrliner is perfect. This blue-eyed blonde never had black eyelashes, has zero desire to draw on my face with a black marker, and doesn't want to look like a hooker with Tuberculosis, a heroin addiction, or a cosplay fetish. However. The item was shipped with zero packing. At best, gross and sleazy. For no discount! It was gross and rude.

👤It is usually sensitive to many ptoducts. No problems with burts bees, glides on well and is black.

👤I only use non toxic makeup because of my sensitive skin. I break out with most natural eyeliners. I like that it is not a twist up. It is hard to apply eyeliner when it is running out, but it does last a long time and is a good value if it doesn't make your eyes puffy or break out. I wish I could use the product but it is hard to do. The black is a nice color. I will give it to my daughter who is not as sensitive.

👤It works well but is a little light. I wish the color was a little bit darker, or that the bees would make a liquid liner. The packaging doesn't say "natural" like most of the products from Burt's bees. The packaging doesn't specify how much of the ingredients are natural, but I assume it's mostly natural.

👤I have been using this pencil for a while. The pencil arrived on time. After using a very hard eyeliner, I found the brown colour to be a pleasant surprise. It glides on the eyelid and is soft. It is easy to apply. It does not smudge on my eyes. The colour still looks nice by the end of the day. The brown colour is soft and can be seen on the eyelid. It is easy to remove. Sometimes I don't remove it with oil separately but rather I just wash my face with soap and see that it has been removed from my eyes without making a mess. There is a It is soft, but sharpens well. I don't make it too sharp. There is no break in the pencil. This is the second eye pencil I have ever used and I have given it four stars. I will be purchasing it again once I run out of the current one or in the other colors if I need to.

10. Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil Chocolate

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil Chocolate

It glides on smoothly and lasts all day without fading or smudge. Light diffuses through the eyeliner pencil to make the whites of eyes appear brighter. The pencil has a built-in sharpener and smudger to help achieve a soft, blended, smoky eye look. The eye makeup formula is safe for sensitive eyes. The Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover can be used to remove this eyeliner.

Brand: Neutrogena

👤A really good eyeliner for blondes. For a while, I thought I would never be able to wear eyeliner again because of the red color, but I tried this one a while back. This brand and type is the only one that doesn't irritate my eyes and undereye skin. I would recommend this eyeliner to anyone who is sensitive to eyeliner.

👤I bought this for my mom, who cannot live without eyeliner. I've bought her many eyeliners. She prefers pens over liquid or gel. I've spent as little as $1 and as much as $25, but never found one that would stay for more than a few hours. She has 20 eyeliners that are ok. I bought this because she never used it and so far it's the only one she will use. She said that it works better than any of the other ones she owns, and that it lasts all day. The smudge end was lost in a few days and that's why I have a 4 star rating. It came right away. She eventually found it.

👤It's easy to apply and gives a nice soft look rather than the sharp outline of a liquid liner. I have a tip for other women with a fair complexion and light colored eyes, stop trying to achieve the "smoky eye" look. It doesn't work for our coloring. This will make you look like the sister of "The Hamburglar".

👤I just got my order and it went on smoothly, I don't have to use eyeliner pens or make me cry. It has been on for at least 15 minutes and my eyes don't feel dry or itchy. It is soft so don't expect crisp lines. I'm planning on using different ones for different accents. I will buy more colors in the future. I have been told for 20 years that I would get used to makeup and not tear up. 3

👤This is the only eyeliner I have found that stays put and doesn't rub off in my waterline. I have been using it for a long time and will not use another one.

👤I switched to this eyeliner after several bouts of blepharitis. I thought my mascara was causing the problem, but after trying several brands without success, I decided to change my eyeliner and the problem was solved. I was devastated to have to switch brands after using L'Oreal's Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner for 10 years. I wear eyeliner everyday and wanted a cheaper alternative that was comparable to my beloved L'Oreal liner, and could be purchased at the drugstore. The only two drugstore brands I could find were Neutrogena liner and Physician's Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil. Both brands did not cause any irritation. The Physician's Formula liner wears off very quickly, which left me with the Neutrogena liner as my best option. I don't notice any fading/wearing off until the end of the day, and this one stays on well compared to my old L'Oreal liner. This Neutrogena eyeliner is a close second to my favorite L'Oreal liner and it does not bother or irritate my eyes at all. I think the Neutrogena liner is just as easy to apply as the L'Oreal liner, and it also has a nice, solid color when applied, which is something I never got with the Physician's Formula eyeliner. If you're looking for a non-irritating eyeliner, Neutrogena is the product for you.

11. L F Cosmetics Retractable Eyeliner Waterproof

L F Cosmetics Retractable Eyeliner Waterproof

The e.l.f. is the ultimate eye pencil. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner checks all your liner requirements. All day wear. This product is waterproof and creamy. The look is incomplete. If you want to have intense eyes that last all day, they recommend you use this retractable eyeliner pencil. If you want a runway-inspired look, apply all over the eyelid as a base for eyeshadow. All ingredients are skin-loving. All of the products are made from skin-loving ingredients, and at good-for-you prices. All e.l.f. products are vegan.

Brand: E.l.f.

👤I think E.L.F. is a terrible company. I have sensitive eyes so that matters, but the liner went on just fine. It burns like saltwater if it runs and gets in your eyes. I wore this to an emotional gathering and started crying. It felt like I ate hot wings and rubbed my eyeballs without washing my hands, not because I was sad, but because it felt like I ate hot wings and rubbed my eyeballs without washing my hands. There is a If you're stable and use this product for school or work, you might be ok. I don't recommend it for spirit-filled church services.

👤This one was really disappointing. I love E.L.F products. They are always a plus because they are cruelty-free. I've been pleased with the E.L.F. brushes and cleaners, eyebrow wax, and powders. After many attempts at using this pen, I could only get a faint line of the coffee color in my eyeliner. I tried to remove the tip, writing on paper and applying it to my eye. Every attempt was a failure. My eyes were puffy and sore after I scratched them with this dry pen. This one is definitely not for sale.

👤How can an eyeliner not work? Nothing comes off when you put it on your eye or hand. It's like using a piece of plastic. I think it was old and dried up because I used it once before. I'm throwing it away because I'm tired of returning things to Amazon.

👤I have used the black for a long time and have enjoyed it, but this review is for the brown. The black does not glide on. It's hard to draw on my eye lids because it's very dry. Not on my water line. The color is nice if you can get it to go on. It's not too dark like a lot of other brown that look black. I'm looking for another brand of brown.

👤The performance and value of the ELF eye pencil is very impressive. I have been using a Palladio waterproof eye pencil but it has traveled outside of where it should be and resulted in a "raccoon eye!" ELF stays put during my day. I have been using ELF for a week in extreme conditions and would recommend anyone looking for a change in eye pencil to try it.

👤I line my waterline and always look for a product that stays on. This item seems to work well. The black is a nice deep color and it doesn't accumulate in the inner eye corners so that you don't have a blob of black there after a few hours. It glides on the eyelid, which is hard to find when you use a pressed powder around the eyes. I would buy it again.

👤I like to use this eyeliner on my water line. It's easy to use and build with intensity in mind. It runs to good and holds longer than any other liner I have used. I like to apply more throughout the day.


What is the best product for eye liners for women pencil brown?

Eye liners for women pencil brown products from Nyx Professional Makeup. In this article about eye liners for women pencil brown you can see why people choose the product. Revlon and Julep are also good brands to look for when you are finding eye liners for women pencil brown.

What are the best brands for eye liners for women pencil brown?

Nyx Professional Makeup, Revlon and Julep are some of the best brands that chosen by people for eye liners for women pencil brown. Find the detail in this article. L'oreal Paris, Revlon and Nyx Professional Makeup are also brands that their products are worth to check.

You May Like

Share Your Story

Your name:
Choose product to comment:
Write your review:
By submitting this review, you are agree that:
  • Your review is based on fact, honest, polite and not harmful to anyone or any brands.
  • We have full right to show or not-to-show your review after moderation.
  • No spamm please :)
We might earn comission for your shopping via our links, it doesn't cost you extra. This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to